Anugerah Pengkritik Filmfare untuk Persembahan Terbaik

1990an

• 1991
  Awarded to Male Actor
• 1992 Dimple Kapadia – Drishti
• 1993 Dimple Kapadia – Rudaali
• 1994
  Awarded to Male Actor
• 1995 Farida Jalal – Mammo
• 1996 Manisha Koirala – Bombay
• 1997 Manisha Koirala – Khamoshi: The Musical

Anugerah Pengkritik Filmfare untuk Pelakon Wanita Terbaik

• 1998 Tabu – Virasat
• 1999 Shefali Shah – Satya

2000an

• 2000 TTabu – Hu Tu Tu
• 2001 Tabu (actress)Tabu – Astitva
• 2002 Karisma Kapoor – Zubeidaa
• 2003 Manisha Koirala – Company (tied with) Rani Mukerji – Saathiya
• 2004 Urmila Matondkar – Bhoot
• 2005 Kareena Kapoor – Dev
• 2006 Rani Mukerji – Black
• 2007 Kareena Kapoor – Omkara
• 2008 Tabu – Cheeni Kum
• 2009 Shahana Goswami – Rock On!!

2010an

• 2010 Mahi Gill – Dev.D
• 2011 Vidya Balan – Ishqiya
• 2012 Priyanka Chopra – 7 Khoon Maaf
• 2013 Richa Chadda – Gangs of Wasseypur
• 2014 Shilpa Shukla – B.A. Pass
• 2015 Alia Bhatt – Highway
• 2016 Kangana Ranaut – Tanu Weds Manu Returns
• 2017 Sonam Kapoor – Neerja
• 2018 Zaira Wasim – Secret Superstar
  • Kangana Ranaut - Rangoon as Julia
  • Sridevi – Mom as Devki Sabarwal
  • Swara Bhaskar - Anaarkali of Aarah as Anaarkali
  • Vidya Balan – Tumhari Sulu as Sulochana Dubey
• 2019 Neena Gupta - Badhaai Ho
  • Anushka Sharma - Sui Dhaaga as Mamta Sharma
  • Alia Bhatt – Raazi as Sehmat Khan
  • Radhika Madan - Pataakha as Champa 'Badki' Kumari
  • Taapsee Pannu - Mulk as Aarti Malhotra/Mohammed
  • Tabu – Andhadhun as Simi